Online Ebook John C Calhoun American Portrait – chiangshistory.org
While not as in depth and critical times as I
would have liked a one volume biography of such a complicated figure as John C Calhoun I feel that Coit have liked for a one volume biography of such a complicated figure as John C Calhoun I feel that Coit a good ob of hitting all of the high notes and helping the reader get a good feel for Calhoun In particular her analysis of Calhoun s transition from being a nationalist to a secessionist was well done with Coit positing through her analysis that the development of his ideas was seamless than is sometimes described in works on Calhoun Overall the reader is left with an understanding of Calhoun as a complicated intellectual who unfortunately utilized his abilities to further the cause of slavery and was indirectly culpable in the dissolution of the Union First off I listened this book with the narration by Charlton Griffin
PART OF THE CHARM OF THIS BOOK WAS THAT of the charm of this book was that voice and diction of the narrator seemed perfectly matched with charm of Coit s languageCalhoun is one of the most important American politicians who never became President And I had been reading a lot about him in other biographies and histories and so I thought it would be good to tackle him directlyThis book is definitely dated a history published in the early 1950s when historical standards were different than today For example she writes in much of a narrative approach making it seem like the events she described happened as she tells him another reviewer described this as historical fiction which I think isn t fair So she isn t great at describing the limits of the historical information and data that she is accessing Another fault is that she is certainly a partisan for Calhoun often explaining away and perhaps not defending his views but rationalizing them given the circumstances of the day I think a modern biography wou. John C Calhoun remains a striking and central figure in American history From 1811 to 1850 he served as representative from South Carolina secretary of war vice president secretary of state and senator.
review ↠ PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Ó Margaret L. CoitOf a Nation or Love this book Calhoun s ideas describe what lead
To The Civil War Andthe Civil War and today in the shadows of the Trump administration This monumental biography of John Caldwell Calhoun illustrates a dying art in American historical writing in which the grandness of the subject is treated with eually grand prose Margaret L Coit sings of the exploits of an epic figure in American history with sufficiently epic style and has produced a masterpiece of classic history From the humble origins of his family to the indelible mark he left upon the troubled American Union Coit captures the full sweep of Calhoun s life from his intimate moments With Family To His Electrifying Addresses Before The Nation In family to his electrifying addresses before the nation In approach Coit harkens to a traditional style of American biography if some scenes are imagined for effect or anecdotes of dubious provenance are inserted they are only meant to emphasize the mythic scope of the personage under consideration Such an approach is anathema to modern scholarship which would also find fault with the lack of social context provided in this work Calhoun is the sole consideration of the author and long discourses on the times in which he lived are largely absent Coit frames Calhoun in his time but does not feel the need to excoriate that time If anything she is able to paint a better picture of America by illustrating how Calhoun represented it than how it shaped him Modern readers will likely be especially put off by Coit s assessment of Calhoun s views on race and slavery which she largely accepts without comment as ust another example of his perspective on the world I would highly recommend John C Calhoun American Portrait for anyone looking for a dense and beautifully written biography of a major American figur. Major influence on every issue of the period A champion of state rights he is an important figure in the drama of expansion ad conflict that is at the heart of American history in the nineteenth centu. Ld be much harsher on Calhoun for his treatment of the slavery issue and his support of nullificationHaving said all that the book is really charming to read or to listen to in my case Her appreciation for Calhoun and her description of South Carolina make the book very interesting And her language has a poetry about it that contemporary histories tend to lack Calhoun is portrayed as a brilliant thinker who fought for
A Lost Cause Ilost cause I it would be good to pair this book with a contemporary account of Calhoun but I found this book
To Be Very Engagingbe very engaging best biography on Calhoun I put this book aside after Chapter 5 It is fictional biography which substitutes adjectives and supposition for the elegant presentation of evidence The author skillfully contextualizes and humanizes Calhoun but does not provide a nuanced exposition of his political philosophy or principled machinations Definitely a biography for its times the pre civil rights era This is definitely a book that has not aged well both in substance and in execution The book itself gives the impression of a Margaret Mitchell novel With its generous use of adjectives similes and metaphors it comes across as a love letter to John C Calhoun Because the biography is written in a narrative style that often second guesses it s characters motives it Is not a book for those looking for a solid historical record of John C Calhoun Biographer Margaret Coit looks at Calhoun s life through the now defunct lens of the Southern Lost Cause However the book is still worth a readlisten to understand the view points and biases of the time Coit write the book and and what historical narrative is people used to defend misguided viewpoints today Similar to the way one would approach viewing DW Griffith s Birth. During the same period he was twice contender for the presidency of the United States From the beginning to the end of his career Calhoun arrested public attention and influenced public opinion having.